Thinking of You

Thinking of You covers the quiet middle ground — not a birthday, not a sympathy card, just letting someone know they crossed your mind. It's one of the most-used categories we have, and for good reason: these are the cards that arrive when nobody's expecting mail.

You'll find gentle florals and nature scenes, comforting sentiments, and a few sets with enough humor to make a hard week lighter. All red rubber, deeply etched and cling-mounted, made in the USA. Pair a sentiment set with a background stamp when you want something you can make five of in one sitting.

Browse by

Brands

Shop by brand

Price Filter

Shop by price

Sort by

Sale
Red rubber stamp set of ten bold block greetings plus a heart and a period, including "let's celebrate", "with sympathy", "thanks a bunch", "hey", "so", "dang", "yay", "happy", "hello" and "hugs".

Lisa Arana

Say it Loud & Clear

$29.00
$29.00
$13.99
High-Quality Red Rubber Stamp Set Made in-house at Unity Stamp Co. designed by Lisa Arana.  Experience the unmatched quality and durability of our red rubber stamp set made in-house from raw...
Red rubber stamp sheet with a girl in a sun hat and flowing dress riding a bicycle away from the viewer, a basket of flowers on the back, beside sentiments reading 'Trust the journey. Even if you don't know where it leads'.

Angiegirl

Savannah Girl

$26.00
High-Quality Red Rubber Stamp Set Made in-house at Unity Stamp Co. designed by Angie Blom.    Experience the unmatched quality and durability of our red rubber stamp set made in-house from raw...
Red rubber stamp sheet with a rugged wooden cross on a grassy rise, alongside 'He is risen' and 'Cast your cares on the Lord and He will sustain you.'

Unity Stamp

He Lives

$29.00
An Easter and encouragement set anchored by a single rugged wooden cross on a grassy rise, with tufts of long grass and small flowers around its base. The cross is drawn with plenty of wood grain, so...
Black-and-white stamp art of LoLa, a fluffy calico kitten, with 'Hi there!' and 'Here's a little reminder that the world is brighter with you in it.'

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Angela Magnuson

LoLa - Rescue Tales

$29.00
“The world is brighter with you in it.” LoLa the calico kitten delivers sunshine to friendship cards, encouragement notes, and every cat lover’s mailbox. 10% of Rescue Tales purchases support animal...
JaKob Rescue Tales stamp: a German Shepherd puppy portrait with a heart and 'Sending you a little courage and a lot of love.'

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Angela Magnuson

JaKob - Rescue Tales

$29.00
“A little courage and a lot of love”. JaKob the German Shepherd pup stands guard over encouragement cards and brave-day wishes. 10% of every Rescue Tales purchase goes to animal rescue causes. Meet...
Line-art red rubber stamp set 'Luna – Rescue Tales' showing a gentle lop-eared bunny with sentiments 'I'm here for you' and 'need anything?'

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Angela Magnuson

Luna - Rescue Tales

$29.00
“I’m here for you.” Luna the gentle lop-eared bunny softens thinking-of-you cards, get-well wishes, and quiet-support mail. 10% of every Rescue Tales purchase helps animal rescue causes. Cuddle up to...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet with a grumpy fluffy cat clutching a heart, paired with reluctant Valentine lines including 'Ugh, fine. You can have my heart.' and 'I love you. (you're welcome)'.

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Lisa Arana

Reluctant Love Pissy Kitty

$29.00
$29.00
$11.60
Making a batch this year? Browse all Valentine rubber stamps or get the words from our guide to 48 Valentine card sayings.“Fine. You matter. Whatever.” A grumpy Siamese begrudg
Red rubber stamp image of Hugo the French Bulldog puppy with 'sending you a whole lotta love' and the Rescue Tales badge

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Angela Magnuson

Hugo - Rescue Tales

$29.00
One dog, one sentiment, one very good cause. Hugo is a French bulldog puppy from the Rescue Tales collection, drawn head-on with bat ears wide, wrinkled brow and a small heart floating above him, and...
Red rubber stamp sheet with a single ruffled bloom on a leafy stem, beside the small script 'missing you'.

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Angela Magnuson

Missing You Little Lady

$28.00
A single ruffled carnation on a long stem with grassy leaves, drawn in fine line work, with a ladybug tucked into the petals near the center. The one sentiment is a small script “missing you“, so the...