Thinking of You

Thinking of You covers the quiet middle ground — not a birthday, not a sympathy card, just letting someone know they crossed your mind. It's one of the most-used categories we have, and for good reason: these are the cards that arrive when nobody's expecting mail.

You'll find gentle florals and nature scenes, comforting sentiments, and a few sets with enough humor to make a hard week lighter. All red rubber, deeply etched and cling-mounted, made in the USA. Pair a sentiment set with a background stamp when you want something you can make five of in one sitting.

Browse by

Brands

Shop by brand

Price Filter

Shop by price
Reset Filter

Sort by

Sale
Line-art stamp sheet of tall calla lilies with the sentiments 'love. healing. peace.', 'I prayed for you' and 'May your love bloom brighter every year.'

Unity Stamp

Lily, Love & Prayers

$29.00
$32.00
$12.80
High-Quality Red Rubber Stamp Set Made in-house at Unity Stamp Co.  Experience the unmatched quality and durability of our red rubber stamp set made in-house from raw materials right here in the USA...
Sale
Red rubber stamp set of ten bold block greetings plus a heart and a period, including "let's celebrate", "with sympathy", "thanks a bunch", "hey", "so", "dang", "yay", "happy", "hello" and "hugs".

Lisa Arana

Say it Loud & Clear

$29.00
$29.00
$13.99
High-Quality Red Rubber Stamp Set Made in-house at Unity Stamp Co. designed by Lisa Arana.  Experience the unmatched quality and durability of our red rubber stamp set made in-house from raw...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet with a grumpy fluffy cat clutching a heart, paired with reluctant Valentine lines including 'Ugh, fine. You can have my heart.' and 'I love you. (you're welcome)'.

Finely Detailed - Unique to Unity - Lisa Arana

Reluctant Love Pissy Kitty

$29.00
$29.00
$11.60
Making a batch this year? Browse all Valentine rubber stamps or get the words from our guide to 48 Valentine card sayings.“Fine. You matter. Whatever.” A grumpy Siamese begrudg
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet with a soft eyed little donkey standing in tall grass, beside 'A LITTLE LOVE JUST FOR YOU' and 'Sending a smile'.

Unity Stamp

Darling Donkey Smiles

$28.00
$28.00
$11.20
Built for the quick, kind note: one donkey, two sentiments and nothing you have to plan around. The little donkey stands in tall grass with oversized ears, a tufted mane and a soft half-smile aimed...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet showing an owl in a knit beanie on a leafy branch, beside 'SENDING YOU ALL THE COZY VIBES.' and 'you are so wise'.

Unity Stamp

Cozy Vibes Owl

$28.00
$28.00
$11.20
“Sending you all the cozy vibes.” An owl bundled into a beanie delivers winter’s warmest wishes, perfect for thinking-of-you cards, long-distance hellos, and cold-weather encouragement. Nestle in...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet with a soft eyed golden puppy and pet loss sentiments including 'I WOOF YOU.' and 'Our pets are the hardest goodbyes.'

Paws for Thought

$28.00
$28.00
$11.20
Lisa Arana drew this puppy with the biggest, wettest eyes she could fit on a face, paws tucked under its chin and ears drooping. It is built for the hard cards: pet sympathy, with “Our pets are the...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet of holiday sympathy sentiments including 'Your loss is in my heart this holiday season.' and 'MAY THE SPIRIT OF CHRISTMAS BRING HEALING TO YOUR HEART.'

Lisa Arana

Christmas Comfort

$28.00
$28.00
$11.20
Christmas Comfort is for the hardest card of the year: the sympathy card that lands during the holidays. Lisa Arana set nine sentiments in a mix of script and clean serif type, and every one of them...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet with a bundled girl in a knit hat carrying a small Christmas tree, beside 'holding you close in my thoughts' and 'let your heart be light'.

Angiegirl

Juniper Girl

$26.00
$26.00
$10.40
A girl in a knit hat and long coat stands beside a fully trimmed Christmas tree, holding a mug in both hands, looking at the ornaments. Angie Blom’s Juniper Girl is the quiet side of the ANGIEgirl...
Sale
Red rubber stamp sheet with a large detailed poinsettia and leaves, alongside 'MAY THE BLESSINGS OF CHRISTMAS FILL YOUR HOME WITH JOY' and 'COMFORT & JOY'.

Lisa Arana

Poinsettia Comfort

$29.00
$29.00
$11.60
Lisa Arana’s Poinsettia Comfort is a large, finely drawn poinsettia with a second smaller bloom tucked beside it, paired with sentiments for a Christmas that is not entirely merry: Holding you close...